Her First Extra Guy Was A Surprise

The very first time that I let another guy fuck my wife was on her birthday, just after our second anniversary.
  
We were on Catalina Island.  My wife had pointed out a guy who she said she thought was sexy.  While she was talking with other people, I managed to slip away and talk with the guy.  I arranged for him to meet us under the pier after we left the popular bar.  

I took my wife down on the beach, and under the pier.   We necked, and I stripped her naked.  She did the same for me.  It was very dark, and we lay down on the wet sand with the low waves touching our feet.  We fondled each other until we were both ready to have sex.  Then I rose up on my hands and knees, and positioned myself so that she thought I was above her ready to make love.  

I had a twinge of guilt for what was coming, but I was too excited to stop.  Besides, by that time the guy had quietly arrived.  He was already naked, and very quickly he was kneeling between her legs.  

He put one hand on the sand and the other on my back.  Then he leaned forward for penetration.  As he entered her, I was tongue-kissing her.  After he pushed in and out of her a few times, I decided that was the time for me to pull back and let her know this was her grand birthday surprise.  

At first she told me not to pull back, and said, "I want you all over me, fucking me deep.  I just want to be fucked like a wild animal.  I want to be held down and force-fucked." 

When I had pulled back all the way, she realized it wasn't me making love to her, but someone else was force-fucking her.  She tried to push him away, but I held her arms so all she could do was lay there while he pounded his meat in and out of her.  

She was already so turned-on that she couldn't stop her passion.  With the forbidden act and the continued force, she started cumming and cumming... the longest and most powerful climax I had ever seen from her.  When he finished, he pulled his condom off, tied it in a knot, and dropped it on the sand before he put his trunks and shirt on as he left.  

While he has doing that, I continued holding her arms.  I slid onto her, and without aiming, slid my dick into her... and animal fucked her.  She got off again, and right after her climax, I finished.  

She didn't want to talk about it for the next few days.  She said it was because she was ashamed of liking it so much and wanting more of it.  She said, "I liked fucking two dicks in a row, and I really do want more of it." 

Little did she know the plans I had in mind for her future fucks.  Oh yes, she saved the guy's condom, and keeps it in the freezer for the memories.