"Dance With Me" by Ellen Hayes (ehayes@nym.alias.net). The rules of this contest said I would interpret the Christmas theme loosely. In this case the story is about a high school Christmas dance, but David doesn't even go into the gym where the dance is being held. While waiting for his date, he is diverted to a different, very romantic location by an exceptionally attractive strange woman, who initiates him into the rites of sexual pleasure. There's a lot more to the story than this, but I really can't say much more without ruining it for you.

The author writes in a flawless style that makes the complex plot easy to follow. This is an extremely good story.