Note: This story was dynamically reformatted for online reading convenience.
 
 Title: My Girlfriend's Sister Carly Part 3.
Keywords:anal,first time,erotic,mf,young,
   This is a continuation of My Girlfriend's Sister Carly Part 1 and Part
2.
   After Carly finished getting ready we left for the movies and we were
out on our first date.  Of course technically I was still in relationship
with her sister, but her sister wasn't home so I couldn't break up with
her. On the way there we made small talk and she held my hand.  She seemed
to be very happy, and I'll confess I was too.  Never in my wildest dreams
did I think I'd go out with a girl that looked this good, and had such a
great personality.
   We went into the theater and one of Michelle's friends, Wendy, spotted
us coming in as she was going out.  She eyeballed us and then she whipped
her phone out and started furiously typing a text message.  As we were
waiting for our movie to start my phone vibrated letting me know I had a
text message.  I knew it was Michelle.  I held the phone so Carly could see
the messages and my replies.
   "Are you at the movies with my fucking sister?"
   "Yes, neither one of us had anything to do so we decided to go see a
movie is that a problem?"
   "Well I don't like it."
   "Why?"
   "I just don't like it.  My sister is a liar and you can't believe a word
she says.  She will try and start trouble between us."
   "Don't be silly we get along great what could she possibly tell me that
would start trouble between us?"
   "IDK."
   I concluded the conversation, "well the movie is about to start and I
really want to see it so I am going to let you go."
   Then I put my phone back in my pocket.
   Carly laughed and said, "she is in a full blown panic."
   I said, "I know, but it is not like she doesn't deserve it."
   I took Carly's hand and we watched the movie together.  The movie wasn't
that memorable, but being there with Carly was.  Holding her hand looking
over at her, watching her laugh and just taking in all of her little looks
as she watched the movie was incredible.  She caught me staring more than
once, and when she did she would always turn to me and flash me that
incredible smile.  As we walked out after the movie and into the parking
lot.  We saw Wendy and one of Michelle's other friends Regan cruising the
parking lot in Wendy's car.  I suspected they were on the lookout for us.
   Carly smiled and asked, "are you sure you are ready for this?"
   I smiled and said, "without a doubt."
   I walked Carly to the passenger door of my car, leaned in and gave her a
kiss on the cheek just as Michelle's friends were passing by where we had
parked.  I closed her door for her and walked around to my side of the car
and got in.  When I got in the car Carly said, "well I bet that got their
attention."
   I asked her what she was in the mood to eat and she said how about Dairy
Queen.  I told her that would be fine.  As we made our way to the Dairy
Queen I noticed Wendy followed us out of the parking lot and down the road
to Dairy Queen.  As we parked they circled around the lot and went back
out.
   My phone started to vibrate again and I pulled it out of my pocket.  Of
course it was Michelle so I held the phone up to where Carly could see the
message.
   "WTF why are you opening my sister's door for her and kissing her on the
cheek?"
   I replied, "I was just being a gentleman like I always am with you.  If
your friends are going to stalk me maybe they ought to come up and say hi?"
   I didn't get a response.
   Carly's phone started to vibrate and she held her phone up so I could
see the text she just got from Michelle.  It said, "WTF are you doing with
my man bitch?"
   She typed a response, "I am not out with Craig."
   Her phone vibrated again, "if you do anything with him I am going to
beat on your slut ass for days when I get home."
   Carly responded, "I think Mike is a big boy and can decide for himself
which sister he wants to be with, but it was so nice of you to go out of
town and leave me all alone with him so I could put my slut moves on him."
   She stuck her phone in her purse and I got out of the car and walked
over to open her door for her.  I noticed Wendy had came back into the
parking lot and had parked 5 spots down from us.  I opened Carly's door,
she got out and I felt like now was the right time to send Michelle a clear
message we were done.
   As Carly stood up I put my hand up under her short miniskirt and cupped
her ass cheek.  She turned to me and flashed that smile.  I kept it there
as we walked towards the door.  As we were about to go in she turned
towards me once again, smiled at me and I French kissed her.
   We went in and ordered our food.  Carly went to get our drinks and then
sat down.  When our food was ready I brought it to our booth.  As I sat
down Wendy and Regan came in and went up to the counter to order something.
I smiled at Carly then she smiled at me and we began to eat.
   My phone vibrated and I picked it up.  There was a pic of my hand on
Carly's ass cheek from when we walked towards the door.  The text with it
said, "yeah fucking right, a real gentleman."
   I decided not to answer as I knew that would stoke her anger even
higher. A few minutes later Carly's phone vibrated.  She showed me the
message.  It was the same pic, but with a different message.  It said, "oh
it is on bitch...  you thought I picked on you and was mean to you when you
were younger well you ain't seen nothing yet bitch."
   I looked at Carly and asked, "are you scared?"
   She smiled and said, "a little."
   I told her not to worry I had an idea.  I sent Rita (Craig's Girlfriend)
a message and asked her what she and Craig were up to.  She told me not
much that Craig had just left for work.  I asked her if she could meet me
and Michelle's sister at Dairy Queen as we needed to talk to her about
something, and that it was important.  She said she would be there in 20
minutes.
   I smiled at Carly and said, "see nothing to worry about."
   We finished up eating and we still had about 10 minutes to kill before
Rita got there.
   Carly said, "I am going to get us some deserts my treat."
   She got up and went to the counter to order.  I got up and went over to
where Wendy and Regan were sitting and asked, "are you two enjoying the
show?"
   They didn't say anything they just nervously looked down at the table
top.  I said, "well make sure you stick around it is about to get
interesting."
   I walked away and went back to our booth and sat down.  Carly came back
with two hot fudge sundaes.  She sat down, handed me mine and then took
hers off the tray.  They were identical except hers had not one, but two
cherries on top while mine had none.
   She smiled and seductively said, "would you like my cherries?"
   It took me a few seconds to get what she was really offering me.  When I
did I asked, "are you sure you want to give them up?"
   She replied, "I was saving them for someone special.  I had often
fantasized that it would be you, but I never thought I'd get the chance.  I
think your officially broken up with my sister now, but shit is going to be
crazy for awhile when my parents and Michelle get back into town.  We have
tonight and tomorrow before that happens and yes, I want to give them both
to you."
   She picked one of the cherries up by the stem.  She slowly and
seductively stuck it in her mouth.  Then she picked the other one up by the
stem and said, "open your mouth."
   I did and she stuck it in my mouth.  We smiled at each other and I
couldn't wait to get back to her place.  We finished our sundaes and a
short time thereafter Rita came in.  I beckoned her over to come and have a
seat.  I looked over at Wendy and Regan.  Wendy was typing furiously on her
phone.  Rita is a big girl and by big I don't mean fat.  She is 6'1″
and was the star athlete on all the girl's sports teams back when we were
in high school.  She works now as a personal trainer at a health club.
   Rita sat down next to Carly, looked at me and asked, "so what is up?"
   I looked at her and said, "I have something to tell you." My facial
expressions let her know it wasn't something good.  I said, "I found out
this morning that Michelle and Craig have been cheating on us with each
other."
   She was shocked.  Not so much about Craig as I think deep down she knew
he was a no good douche bag, but more so about Michelle because she had
been friends with her from way back.
   I said, "I am sorry."
   She said, "this isn't the first time he has done it to me, but do you
have any proof it is with Michelle as me and her have been friends since
grade school and I can't believe she would do that to me."
   Carly explained the whole story to her starting with how she came home
from school early one Wednesday and walked in on them having anal sex.  She
told her how Michelle had threatened her if she told anyone about it, about
how she had a crush on me for the longest time and how she had finally told
me after I had taken care of her when she came home sick.
   Rita, smiled and said, "so does she know you two are together now?"
   I smiled and said, "we broadcasted that to her about a half hour ago
when we got here." I slid her my phone so she could see the text message
and the pic that Michelle had sent me.  I also gestured with my head over
towards Wendy and Regan.
   Rita asked Carly, "so your sister threatened to beat you for stealing a
guy she was cheating on after she threatened to beat you if you told anyone
she was cheating?"
   Carly nodded her head yes.  I could tell she was a bit intimidated by
Rita's size and presence.
   Rita put her arm around her and said, "I promise you that won't happen.
Just make sure I am at your house when Michelle gets home from her trip.  I
will make sure that she won't lay a hand on you ever."
   We told her we would call her when we knew for sure when she was going
to be home.  She excused herself and walked over to Wendy and Regan and sat
down with them.  It appeared as though they were having an intense
conversation.  Wendy and Regan were Rita's friends too.  We wanted to get
back to Carly's place so we could enjoy each others company before the shit
hit the fan.  As we walked towards the door to leave Wendy got up, walked
over towards me and tapped me on the shoulder.
   She gave me a hug and said, "I am so sorry Rita just told us what was
going on, and we aren't going to answer any of her calls or texts until
Rita gets done with her.  You two make a cute couple...  you should give it
a try."
   She gave Carly a hug and went back over to her booth.  We left and as we
got in the car Carly said, "OMFG that was awesome."
   On the drive back I kept thinking about taking Carly's virginity.  I
defiantly wanted to and was excited about the prospect, but I had never
popped a girl before so I was scared that I was going to hurt her.
   She asked me, "what is the matter Mike?"
   I said, "I want more than anything in the world to have sex with you,
but I am afraid I will hurt you.  I have never taken a girl's virginity
before."
   She leaned into me and said, "don't worry I am sure it will be fine."
The she leaned back onto her side of the car and started texting someone. I
assumed she was talking to one of her girlfriends so I didn't ask.
   Once we got back to her place we went up to her room.  She started
undressing and so did I.
   She asked me with a smile on her face, "Mike, would you eat my pussy
before you fuck me?"
   As we stood there naked.  I didn't answer her.  I kissed her on the
mouth and then I started kissing her on her neck.  I slowly worked my way
down to her breasts.  I softly pushed her back onto her bed.  I got onto
her bed with her and started kissing her breasts and gently sucking on her
erect nipples.
   She moaned, "oh fuck Mike."
   I started kissing her perfectly flat belly and her navel which was
adorned with the sexist bell button ring.  I ran my hand along the top of
her pubic area and then around the crease where her thighs meet her legs. I
parted her legs.  Her smell was heavenly.  I softly kissed her pussy.  Then
I put my tongue on her clit.  I slowly started licking it and then I dipped
back down and licked her pussy lips.  I did this alternating back and forth
for a few minutes as she rubbed my hair with her fingers while moaning in
pleasure.
   After about five minutes had passed she moaned, "oh Mike you are making
me cum ah ah ah oh."
   I was rewarded with a gush of her pussy juice.  I took as much into my
mouth as I could.  I got up from in between her legs and kissed her.  Her
smell and her cum were all over my face.  We made out for a few minutes.
   As our tongues separated she said, "Mike, I love you."
   I said, "I love you too Carly."
   She replied, "then fuck me."
   I started to lift up to enter her missionary and take her cherry when
she said, "hold on my girlfriend told me how to do this."
   She rolled over, got on top of me straddling my legs, looked down at me
and said, "I sent her a text when we were in the car she said for me to get
on top that way I can make sure we get a clean break."
   She grabbed my cock and lined the tip if it up.  She looked down at me
and said, "it will be ok I promise, I am on the shot so cum in me."
   She forcefully slid down onto my cock and as I tore through her hymen
she moaned, "oh fuck that hurts."
   I asked her, "are you ok?"
   She smiled and said, "yeah, just give me a minute for my body to
recover."
   After what seemed like an eternity, but was really just a couple of
minutes she started slowly moving up and down on my cock.
   "Oh, Mike I can't believe your cock is inside of me."
   I said, "I can't believe it either, but I have wanted you for so long
too." Her pussy felt incredibly tight and in fact it was the tightest one I
had ever felt.  Just the sight of this incredible looking 18 year old
bouncing up and down on my cock was enough to make me want to blow.
   She continued to slowly ride me and she started rubbing her breasts
seductively as she did.  She moaned, "oh fuck, oh fuck, oh fuck tonight all
my dreams are coming true."
   "Oh, fuck mine too."
   She picked up the pace and started bouncing up and down on my cock
harder.  "Oh fuck Mike I want you to cum.  I want you to cum inside me."
   After a few more minutes of her riding hard I was ready to cum.  I said,
"oh fuck, oh fuck Carly, I am going to cum."
   "Cum for me...  cum inside me."
   "Oh fuck Carly, ah, ah I and I came inside her."
   She slid off the top of me and gave me a kiss.  She said, "oh my god
that was amazing."
   I said, "yes it was."
   She snuggled up to my side and I held her.  What a strange and
incredible weekend it had been.  Michelle's betrayal didn't even hurt.  In
fact I really didn't even give Michelle a second thought other than I was
afraid she might find ways to make me and Carly's relationship difficult.
   pics---->> http://bit.ly/1D1q3qp
  
My Girlfriends Sister Carly Part 3