Note: This story was dynamically reformatted for online reading convenience.
 
 Title: My Girlfriend's Sister Carly Part 2.
Keywords: erotic,cheating,young,teen,anal,mf,
   This is a continuation of My Girlfriend's Sister Carly.
   I couldn't believe it Michelle had been cheating on me, but as soon as
it came out of Carly's mouth I knew it was true.  Michelle had cut way back
on the frequency we had sex, and she had been acting kind of strange.  A
lot of times I would call her on her phone and she wouldn't pick up.  She
often answered simple questions about how her day went very vaguely.
   I asked, "who is she cheating with?"
   Carly replied, "Craig."
   Craig is like the world's biggest douche bag, but now that I had thought
about it we had gone out on a lot of couples dates with Craig and his
girlfriend Rita.  Rita was very sweet, but not Craig in fact I had
witnessed things he said to Rita that were borderline abusive.
   "Why are girl's attracted to douche bags?" I asked Carly.
   "Look I get that your upset, but I think you need to focus on the
positive."
   "What would that be?" I asked.
   Carly smiled and said, "me."
   "What do you mean?" I asked.
   "Well if sucking your dick and swallowing your cum isn't a big enough
hint that I like you then I don't know what is," said Carly.
   "You mean this wasn't just a onetime thing?" I asked.
   "I hope not," she replied smiling.
   I have known you since I was fourteen, and I have had a crush on you
since then.  You were always so sweet and nice to me even when my sister
wasn't.  I told myself it could never happen because you were my sister's
boyfriend, but once she cheated on you and after how you took care of me
last night I don't care how it makes that selfish bitch feel.
   My head was spinning Carly was definitely an upgrade over her sister.  I
would be going from a seven to a ten.  Oh well I thought even if it doesn't
work out with Carly screwing Michelle over by fucking her sister would be
the ultimate payback so I grabbed Carly and kissed her.  I moved my hands
down toward her pussy and she stopped me.
   "Wait there is something I have to tell you," Carly said.
   I told her she could tell me anything.
   "I am a virgin," she said.
   "No way," I said in a shocked tone.
   "Let me guess my sister told you I was a slut?" she asked.
   I stuttered and stammered and just sort of sheepishly acknowledged that
was how Michelle often spoke of her.
   "It is called projection, " she said.
   I said, "but you dress so sexy."
   She smiled and said, "maybe, that is because I have been trying to get
someone to notice me."
   I playfully asked, "has it worked?"
   She smiled and said, "I think so there is this one boy that always hangs
out at the bottom of the stairs trying to look up my skirt."
   My face turned red and I sheepishly asked, "so you know about that?"
   "Yeah, why do you think I come downstairs to use that mirror when I have
one in my room and one in the upstairs bathroom?" She asked with a look of
satisfaction on her face.
   I moved in and kissed her and she kissed me back.  I started kissing
down her neck, and then I kissed her breasts and sucked on her nipples.  I
tentatively started moving my hand down towards her pussy hoping I wouldn't
get turned away again.
   "Just because I am a virgin doesn't mean I don't like for it to be
touched," she said as she grabbed my hand and put it on her pussy that was
still covered by her thin panties.
   I sat up and moved closer and slowly and teasingly ran my fingers over
her slit on top of her underwear making sure to graze her clit.
   She cooed, "ah ah ah oh Mike you don't know how long I have waited for
this." I moved down on the bed pulled her legs apart and pulled her panties
down.  She was shaved completely bald.  I stuck the tip of my finger into
her pussy and used her pussy juice to lube her clit as I rubbed my finger
over it.
   She bit her lip and seductively said, "eat my pussy Mike make me cum." I
put my head between her legs and inhaled deeply through my nostrils her
scent was intoxicating.
   She looked down at me and asked, "do you like how I smell?"
   "Oh yes, you smell incredibly sweet," I said.
   She laughed and said, "well better than last night anyway."
   I gently touched her clit with just the tip of my tongue.
   She let out a seductive sigh and said, "ah ah ah fucking don't tease me
I need to cum."
   I dove in and started eating her pussy.  Her taste and her scent were
both so much sweeter than her sister's.  She moaned and cooed in pleasure
and her hips bucked whenever she came.  After I had brought her off twice
this way I went a little lower and touched her asshole with the tip of my
tongue to see if she was receptive to that sort of thing.
   "Oh fuck yeah, I love having my ass licked," she said as she started
rubbing her clit.
   I dove in and ate her ass.  It was the first time I had ever ate a
girl's ass.  With her cum running down onto it didn't taste bad, and it was
a fascinating new experience for me.  I had tried to play with Michelle's
ass, but early on in the relationship she had made it clear her ass was a
no go zone.
   As I continued to lick Carly's ass she started screaming, "oh fuck yeah
yeah yeah ah ah ah." Her hips bucked and I felt her asshole rapidly clench
and unclench as she came.  She grabbed me by my hair and pulled me back up
to her face.  She French kissed me without any hint of concern that my
tongue had spent the last ten minutes licking her ass.
   "That was the best one of the day," she said smiling.
   I told myself fuck that cheating whore Michelle her sister was so much
better in terms of looks and personality.  As we sat there in her bed, I
touched the side of her face gently with my hand and said, "I want to be
with you."
   She was happy and said, "I want that too, but it is going to get messy
with my sister."
   I said, "I know."
   We sat there in her bed silently for a few minutes and then she asked, "
why don't we go out to the movies and get something to eat?" she asked.
   I said "ok."
   She said with a big smile on her face, "meet me in the bathroom and we
can take another shower together."
   We both got up.  She headed to the bathroom and I headed to Michelle's
room to get some cloths.  I saw my phone sitting on the night stand so I
picked it up.  I had seven missed calls from Michelle and a bunch of missed
texts asking where I was.  I made my way into the bathroom and showed Carly
the missed calls and texts.  She grabbed the phone and typed a reply,
"sorry, I was sleeping what do you need?"
   We walked into the shower together.  I sat my phone down on the ledge
next to Carly's.  Carly got down on her knees and stuck my cock in her
mouth and started giving me some mouth, tongue and hand action.  Just when
I was really getting into it Carly's phone went off.  She took her mouth
off my cock, moved out of the water stream, slid the shower door open and
grabbed her phone.
   "It is Michelle I am going to answer it," she said.
   "Hello," Michelle said.
   Carly asked, "what is it I am in the shower?"
   Michelle asked, "Mike hasn't answered his phone all morning and then he
just replied with a short text have you seen him?"
   "No, I haven't seen him as I just got up myself maybe you should call
Craig and have him come over and check on him." she said in a mocking
fashion.
   Smugly Michelle said, "shut up bitch!  Your just jealous I have two guys
and you don't have any."
   Carly grabbed me by the dick, pulled me close and made a some very loud
sucking noises as she did a couple of stokes up and down my cock.
   "Pop slurp, pop slurp, umm, sorry I am busy doing something right now,"
she said as she made some more noisy slurping sounds.
   "ARE YOU SUCKING A DICK?"
   "Pop slurp umm, pop slurp umm, Yea."
   "Fuck, I can't believe Mike let you have a guy over at the house I am
going to tell mom and dad."
   Carly said, "pop slurp umm, pop slurp umm, go ahead and tell them I will
tell mom, dad and Mike how you and Craig have been fucking at the house
every Wednesday afternoon, and how when I walked in on you two Craig was
balls deep in your ass."
   I said to myself what a whore!  She wouldn't give her ass up to me, but
she fucking gave it to Craig?
   "YOU BITCH!" Said Michelle.
   Just then I felt myself about to pop, "ah ah fuck ah Carly." I started
to cum and Carly caught some of it in her mouth, but let a lot of it run
all over her face."
   Carly said, "sorry bitch, I had to swallow my man's cum."
   "YOU FUCKING WHORE I AM GOING TO KICK YOUR ASS WHEN I GET HOME," and
then she hung up.
   Carly stood back up and French Kissed me.  She said, "sorry, I wanted
you to hear it from her so you knew I was telling you the truth."
   "I knew you were telling the truth the minute you told me," I said.  My
phone started to vibrate and I opened the shower door and picked it up.  It
was a text from Michelle.
   "Do you know Carly has a guy in the house?"
   I replied, "yeah, it is no big deal she asked me first."
   "No big fucking deal?  She was sucking his cock while she was on the
phone with me!"
   I replied, "like I said no big deal she is 18 and entitled to have some
fun when her parents are out of town.  I mean it is not like you haven't
done worse."
   "WTF do mean about me doing worse?"
   I replied, "nothing, just that we do stuff behind your parents back
too."
   "Oh sorry, well I'll be home Sunday evening...  I love you and miss
you."
   I replied with, "I love you too."
   Carly laughed.  We finished washing off and both got out of the shower.
It took me all of five minutes to get dressed.  I got to spend the next 30
minutes watching her get ready.  She let me pick out her underwear and her
outfit.  I picked out something very sexy as I wanted everyone to see her
at her best and I wanted them to see that I was with her.
   pics---->> http://bit.ly/1D1q3qp
  
My Girlfriends Sister Carly Part  2