"Douglas and Penelope" by Gordie D (GordonD103@aol.com).
Doug and Penny have a chaste courtship, fall in love, get married, and have a very nice wedding night. That's about it, except that a few details add a lot of spice. As Doug said afterwards: "That was really unbelievable. I hope she's not expecting it to be like this every night, though . . ."
Doug and Penny take turns telling the story, and so we get independent verification of what each one knows and feels about the various events. This was a very good approach to a very good story.