MUSICAL CAPTORS

BY JILL THE SUB

[ part 5 ]

Scott & Jill

“So this is why you were in such a hurry to get me out of the house, and why Amanda suddenly couldn’t remember why she needed to talk to me that was so urgent. Get off of her.”

“Scott, wait, I can explain, ummm….”

But Scott had listened to Jill enough for one day, and was ready to take matters into his own hands. He jumped up onto the bed and separated his neighbor and his girlfriend, and pulled Jill away from Elai.

“Turn around and face the wall.”

“What? Why?”

“Just do it. Right now.”

“Scott, look, I’m sorry, let me explain…”

“Jill, it’s your turn to be the prisoner. Either you take your punishment, or I’ll tell everyone in school what you were doing in here. And my parents.”

Jill was caught, and knew it. She could live with being called new names at school, she’d had to live with it before. Only this would be worse. But she couldn’t stand it if Scott’s parents told her she wasn’t welcome here anymore. With no choice, she turned and faced the wall.

“Hands behind your back.” She obeyed. Scott took one of the bandannas he’d saved from this morning, a white one, and tied Jill’s hands together, with a good, tight knot. Then he took a second out and tied it in the opposite direction of the first one, crossing the knots so she couldn’t untie them.

Jill watched, trying to think of what to say or do, as Scott whipped the dishtowel off of Elai’s feet, releasing the knot with a quick flourish. Then he rolled her over and untied the bandanna holding her hands. Elai reached up and took off her gag, pulling it down to hang around her neck, not bothering to untie it, being more concerned about pulling up her panties and jeans.

As Elai stood up off the bed to pull her clothes back on, Scott pushed Jill down in her place on the bed. "Scott, I…”

“I think we’ve heard enough out of you today,” and he forced a bandanna into her mouth, stuffing it in, and then re-folded the dishtowel into a long band, and gagged her the way he had with Amanda earlier.

“Now let’s make sure she can’t leave until we decide what to do with her,” and he went to tie her feet but realized he was out of bandannas. “Come here, sweetie,” he motioned to Elai, then picked the knot loose from the bandanna that was still hanging around her neck. Once he had that free, he used it to pin Jill’s ankles together, and knotted it tightly to bind them in place.

Now that Jill was secure, he turned his attention back to Elai. “Are you okay?”

She nodded. “She didn’t hurt me. I think she was just going to, ummm….”

Scott suddenly noticed the cigar box lying open on the bed. Then his eyes fell on the large dildo laying by it. “I don’t believe this. She was going to use this on you?”

Elai shivvered, but from relief or excitement, maybe she didn’t even know herself.

“Well, turnabout is fair play, I guess.” Scott started to unbutton the top of Jill’s cutoff jean shorts.

“Nmmmfffff!!!” Jill shook her head, no! What did Scott think he was doing?? She turned her body to try to keep him away from her pants.

“Oh, no you don’t. You don’t get away that easy. You should’ve thought of that before you started bringing toys into the game.” And he again, with more determination and using all his strength, rolled her body back to face him, so he could get at the buttons and zipper on her cutoffs. They were quite tight on her- the “Daisy Dukes” were generally worn a size or so too small to have the right effect on the male mind and anatomy. Scott had to work to roll them down off Jill’s hips, and her panties followed in short order, until both were tangled around her knees.

They discovered that Jill was a natual blonde. Her love nest was even more fine and downy than Elai’s was. Jill blushed with embarrassment to be seen naked by both of them. She thought Elai might have put a stop to it, but Elai seemed pre-occupied with her own thoughts, or maybe just agreed with Scott that turnabout was fair play in this game.

Scott took the dildo and placed it in Jill’s love nest, her little blonde bush. Jill had been quite aroused by what she was doing, but Jill wasn’t that wet, and the dildo was a good size- she wished Elai had stopped him, or at the very least educated him about lubricant.

Scott started working the head of the dildo up inside her, with a gentle, but firm and insistent swirling motion, and each pass guided it deeper and deeper into her. Jill was very relieved he didn’t just shove it straight up into her like a dagger, which probably would’ve done serious damage. As it was, her body was able to adjust to the shape, and she had used it before, but of course then it was guided by her own hand, and she had only used it when she was wet and wild with thoughts of what she’d do to Elai.

When Scott was satisfied that the plastic plaything was snugly up inside Jill, he turned back to the cigar box. “Now, what about this one?”

“Which one?” asked Elai.

“Mifff vmmm?” asked Jill.

“This one,” said Scott, holding up a second one with a more unusual shape. “Must be the butt plug.”

“Really?” said Elai, genuinely curious.

Scott reached down with both hands, and firmly rolled Jill onto her tummy, face down. Jill’s eyes were wide as saucers. There was absolutely no way he was putting anything up her ass. Scott held up the sex toy. “It’s narrow here at the head, to get it in, then it expands, then its narrow at the bottom. That way when the sphincter closes up around it, it traps it in place.”

“What’s this T-shape thingy here?”

“That’s the crossbar, so when her anal muscle contracts and sucks it inside her, it isn’t lost forever- the crossbar keeps it from going too far so it can be removed again.”

“That looks way too big to go in someone’s ass.”

“We’ll see.” Scott pressed the tip up to the opening of Jill’s twitching rosette, and as soon as it touched her, Jill went absolutely wild!!!

“Holy smoke!” Scott said in surprise, as Jill suddenly began thrashing, bucking, and twisting to get loose from her bonds and get away! “Help me hold her down!!”

Elai got on the bed with Scott, and pinned Jill’s shoulders to the bed, as Scott lay across her legs to stop their desperately squirming captive. Scott again got the butt plug back up to her asshole, and started trying to insert it as he had the dildo. Jill moaned in pitiful despair- how could they be doing this to her?

“Hey, calm down,” said Elai. “It’s only the same thing you were about to do to me. Fair’s fair, Jill.” But Jill shook her head- she’d never used the butt plug before, she still had a virgin ass.

As Scott tried to introduce the butt plug, Jill’s anal muscles clamped down to prevent entry. “I think you’re right,” he said to Elai. “I don’t think this will fit.”

“Oh, maybe that’s what all this is for,” and Elai held up the jar of vaseline that Jill had prepared prior to ‘kidnapping’ Elai from the living room.

“Okay, let’s try that.” Scott dipped his fingers into the greasy lubricant and scooped out a healthy sized dollop. He started smearing onto the head of the butt plug. Then he took the remainder and began coating Jill’s ass, the crack and then right at the asshole. Finally, he started working his fingers up into her hole. Jill moaned deep in her gag feeling her neighbor’s finger up her ass, as her anal muscle instinctively clamped down on it to prevent the intrusion. That just made it all the more erotic as he pushed against the resistance, forcing his way inside.

As he withdrew his finger with a slick pop, and gave her a playful little flick with his fingers, he again returned to trying to get the butt plug up inside her. Freshly greased and lubed up, the slippery plastic was more smooth, and her ass pucker was waxed to meet it. He put the toy to her rosette and started working it slowly, methodically, deviously, insistently, up into her anal cavity. Her ass muscles clamped down on the anal invader, but she was just no match for it. She moaned into the gag, tears leaking from her eyes, as she felt her ass stretched out of shape. The moaning gave way to little grunts of effort as she pushed back against the butt plug, to push it past the point of her resistance.

“Uhmff! Uhnnnffff! Uhhrrrrmmmffff!!!”

And finally, it slid into place, and her sphincter clamped down as it was drawn up inside her by the pressure of her ass muscles contracting. She felt the T-shaped crossbar tight across her ass, holding the artificial phallus lodged in her ass.

“And now that its in place, you just throw the switch,” said Scott.

“Switch?” Said Elai.

“Fmmmrrrrk!” shouted Jill into the gag.

Scott touched a small stud on the device, moving it one notch with a small “click”. The butt plug hummed merrily to life inside Jill, buzzing away with a sweet little vibration. Jill’s eyes crossed and she gasped for breath as the plastic thing up her ass started moving around in her.

“Ohhh, check the other one, I bet it does that, too,” cooed Elai.

Scott rolled Jill back over, and found the dildo also had a switch, and he bumped that up two notches. Jill felt the dildo dancing on her little pleasure spot, and she began rocking and moaning with unimaginable sensations. Her mind was exploding in all directions. Was this torture or salvation?

Elai, watching her, was starting to feel left out. She still didn’t know if she was ‘grateful’ for her rescue by Scott, and knew she wasn’t grateful for her ‘rescue’ by Jill. She’d been brought up to the brink of arousal twice today, and pulled back each time, and here was Jill climbing towards what looked like it was going to be a powerful orgasm, and Elai wanted one of her own.

“So, Scott, now that your prisoner has been punished, how about we go back to where we left off?”

Scott had been unable to tear his eyes away from Jill, squirming and wiggling and bouncing around, she was quite a sight. “Umm, yeah, okay, but I don’t know if we should leave her here alone.”

Elai was not about to have Scott make love to her with Jill as a witness, no matter how distracted Jill was. “Well, have Amanda watch her.”

Scott didn’t know if Amanda was old enough for this part of the prisoner game. If he’d known today would turn out anything like this, he would’ve just sent her to school this morning in the first place, but then none of the rest of this probably would’ve happened either. And, of course, he had Elai hooked on the prisoner game now, but if she didn’t get something to show for it soon….

“Okay, we’ll do this. Let’s put Jill’s shorts back up in place, that will cover over the vibrating dildoes. Then we’ll put some blankets over her to muffle the buzzing sounds, and tell Amanda that she’s been so good today, she’s been promoted to guard, with her very own prisoner."

They got Jill’s panties back up in place over her well-greased ass and her damp blonde bush, then tried to get her cutoff jeans back up on her hips. Being a size or two too small, this took some extra effort, and they were tight on her- which only helped drive the sex toys further up into place. Then they zipped her up real good, buttoned her pants, and gave her a groping hug to check that her new “friends” couldn’t be seen or felt from the outside. They could, but one had to put their hand in the right spot to feel what Jill had packed inside her.

Next, they pulled back the covers, and put a towel down under Jill’s crotch and ass, to catch any leaks that made their way out of her shorty shorts, and rolled her into bed, without even bothering to take her sneakers off. They pulled the covers and quilt over her, and tucked her into bed, leaving just her gagged face propped up on the pillow.

They called Amanda in and told her of her new job as guard, and said the two of them got to watch TV in their parents’ room, because Scott & Elai wanted to watch TV in the living room…alone. Amanda went and got her juice and cookies, and came racing back to the bedroom, and sprang up on the bed next to Jill. She gave Jill a big kiss on the forehead, and didn’t seem to notice Jill was quivvering under the blankets, and that she was sweating hard, and moaning with insistent, desperate, helpless little grunts. Scott & Elai took off back to the Living Room.