Neither girl had talked much as they walked home as both were thinking about what had happened. Lindsay especially was deep in thought. She’d never admit the thought to anyone but she wanted more of what she had experienced. The whole adventure haunted her all night. She didn’t sleep to well that night. Her mind wouldn’t shut down as it kept replaying her experience.

The girls met again the next day at school. The previous day was mentioned but neither spoke much about it. Both were a little shy and didn’t want to admit their desires to the other. Tina had asked Lindsay if she wanted to meet after school but Lindsay said she had to do some things for her mother but she would be over on Saturday.

Alone Lindsay walked down the street. She had lied to her friend but didn’t know how to tell Tina what she really had planned and didn’t want Tina with her this time either. She walked up and knocked on the door.

She blushed a little as it opened but managed a soft “Hi”. Andy smiled and invited her in, closing the door behind her. She put her books down and stood, half smiling and half blushing with embarrassment.

“You liked yesterday,” Andy said softly. Lindsay’s eyes dropped as she nodded her head. “Come on,” Andy ordered as he went into the living room followed by Lindsay.

Andy sat on the couch and guided Lindsay to a position standing in front of him. He reached out slowly and took hold of her belt gently. “OK?” he asked. Lindsay nodded. Her mind was spinning. She knew what he was going to do but seemed powerless to say no even though the idea frightened her. Slowly Andy unbuckled her belt and undid her pants. His hand reached for her zipper and he lowered it.

Lindsay could feel her legs shaking. A man was going to take her pants off. As her mind screamed “No!” the pants fell to the floor. With Andy’s help she stepped out of them. She knew she wasn’t “supposed” to let him do what he was doing but she wanted him to. The delay of having to remove her shoes only seemed to excite her more.

Andy reached up and grabbed her top, pulling it up. Lindsay raised her arms letting him pull it off. “”Turn around,” he told her. As she did, his hands went to her bra. He unhooked it and pushed the straps from her shoulders. She shivered as the bra slid down her arms to the floor.

Lindsay felt his hands on her hips and fingers slid into the waistband of her panties. She couldn’t stop the redness from tinting her face as her panties began to slide down. She breathed deeply. Her instinct was to grasp them, keeping herself covered, but her excitement wouldn’t let her. The panties crumpled at her ankles. Without being told, she stepped out of them. The only thing keeping her from being completely nude now was her socks. Although they didn’t cover anything, it was comforting to have something on anyway.

“Turn around,” Andy said softly. For a moment Lindsay hesitated. For all practical purposes she was naked and she had let Andy strip her but turning around meant he would be able to see that which she had always tried to protect. Granted, he had already seen her but this seemed different. There was no pretense of getting spanked or anything. She was embarrassed but at the same time wanted him to see her. Slowly she turned, bring her hands together in front of her pussy.

She saw Andy smiling. “Very pretty,” he complimented. That made Lindsay smile too. She let her hands drop to her sides. “Want me to get naked for you?” he asked. Lindsay’s face turned red as she nodded.

Andy stood and his clothes came off. Lindsay watched wide-eyed as his manhood came into view. It was standing straight up against his belly. The redness was still in her face but from excitement now. Seeing him naked and him seeing her naked was enjoyable instead of being embarrassing like she thought it would be.

“Want to try something new?” Andy asked. Lindsay wasn’t sure what he wanted but was willing to try. She watched as he lay down on the floor. “OK, straddle me and sit down.”

Not sure what she was supposed to do, Lindsay sat on his thighs. “Move up a little,” Andy told her. She scooted up a little only to have Andy tell her more. She complied and ended up sitting so his cock was directly under her. It was strange to feel his hardness touching between her legs but the feeling was wonderful. “Try moving back and forth a little now,” he said.

Lindsay did as she was asked. She couldn’t stop the smile from coming over her face as she felt her pussy lips part and Andy’s cock slide between them. Soon her eyes were closing. The sensations between her legs were like nothing she had ever felt before. She could feel the wetness forming in her pussy.

“Lean forward,” Andy told her.

“Huh?” she blurted, her mind not working properly with all the new sensations filling it.

“Lean forward,” he repeated. Lindsay leaned only to have Andy coax her to lean more. Finally she was almost lying on his chest. “Lift your butt a little,” he requested. As she did, his hand slid between them. Lindsay felt something touch her love hole. “When you’re ready, push down,” Andy softly said.

Lindsay’s mind was in turmoil. Her pussy was dripping with arousal but there was now a cock poking its head into her. Nothing had penetrated her but she was scared. She had heard all the stories of what it felt like to get fucked. Her friends had all talked about how much the first time would hurt but he had felt so good gliding along her slit. Even the slight parting of her pussy lips by his cock felt good. Lindsay was still frozen with fright.

For what seemed like ages, the two remained motionless and silent. Lindsay’s legs were beginning to tire but she wasn’t sure what to do. As she started to weaken, her body lowered a little. The sensation surprised her. Instead of the hurt she expected, the increased pressure in her pussy caused by Andy’s cock felt better. Tentatively she lowered a little more, only a fraction of an inch but it still felt good. Slowly she let herself down a little more.

She began to feel some pressure in her belly. It felt like something was being stretched. She knew what it was and stopped. Any further and she would break her cherry. She backed off and lowered again with the same result. Andy’s cock felt great inside her but he wasn’t in much yet.

“It’s up to you,” Andy muttered.

“Will it hurt?” questioned Lindsay.

“Some… but then it won’t hurt again. It will feel better each time after this,” Andy answered.

That wasn’t what Lindsay wanted to hear. She had hoped he would have said no. She pushed down again slightly. It began to hurt a little so she eased up. Again she tried with the same result. “I’m afraid,” she muttered.

“Once you do it, it will never hurt again. It will feel good. It’s up to you,” he repeated.

Lindsay continued to hold herself up above Andy but his cock remained at her entrance. Occasionally she would push down some then stop. His cock did feel nice between her legs but she still wasn’t sure. As she tired she made her decision. Without warning she let herself go and crashed down on Andy. “Oh!” she squeaked as his cock seemed to stab through her. Tears came to her eyes as she muttered, “It hurts…”

“It will feel better in a minute,” Andy consoled as he cuddled the tearful girl. Lindsay remained still as that burning sensation seemed to light her belly on fire. As Andy had promised, however, the hurt began to diminish.

Andy felt her begin to relax. “You can start moving if you want to. It will feel good.”

“No! I don’t want to. It will hurt more. Please don’t make me,” she pleaded.

“You’ve got to move sometime. Even if it’s to get off. Just try,” Andy encouraged.

His soothing voice gave her courage and Lindsay moved a little. He was right. She was still tender but it felt good. Slowly she moved more and the pleasure increased. Soon she was bouncing freely and starting to moan.

This was nothing like taking his cock in her ass. When she had done that, the hurt had just dulled but this way felt great! Andy’s breath was warm on her neck. He was beginning to make soft grunting sounds which excited her. She was actually pleasing a man.

Lindsay was tiring from first holding herself up, now moving herself. The sensation her pussy was producing was worth it though. “I’m gonna cum!” Andy groaned. Suddenly he seemed to be sliding into her easier. His hands pushed down on her bare ass stopping her movements. She had nuzzled her head into his neck so he couldn’t see her but a big smile covered her face.

They lay together motionless for a while. Lindsay could feel his cock getting smaller inside her. His hands went to her hips and he lifted her. She winced as his cock pulled out. He gently placed her beside him and reached for her pussy. As he began to rub, he asked, “Are you OK?”

She smiled at him and answered, “Yeah… Can we do it again?”

Andy chuckled. “Well, it will be a little while before I’m ready. Think you can wait?”

“Will you keep rubbing?” Lindsay grinned.

Not only did Andy fuck her again, he did it two more times. As she walked home there was a big smile on her face. Her only problem was cum was still seeping out of her causing a wet spot. Her once on fire pussy was getting chilled by the cool air. It was worth it though.