Creamy Pies for My Sisters by Tray



Creamy Pies for My Sisters


I couldn't help but look up under the hem of Cindy's little sundress as she rode up to me on her new bike. She had just gotten it for her sixth birthday. My eyes were immediately drawn to the narrow patch of white cotton in the crotch of her panties. I couldn't help but notice how the front of the bike seat was wedged firmly between her meaty little pussy lips. As she moved back and forth on the seat, it would dig deeper between the lips of her little baby pussy.

As I continued to sit gazing at my little sister's crotch, and how the material in the crotch of those panties hugged the lips of her pussy. I started to think about how lucky that bike seat was. I would have given anything to have my little sister riding my face like she was riding that bike seat. My cock started to stiffen as my mind continued to wander.

I was now back several years earlier in my mind. Back to a time, when my younger sister Ann, had just turned seven years old. I was thirteen at the time, and had just found the pleasures of playing with my cock.

I found Ann playing in her room one day while my mother was gone running errands, and then coaxed her in to playing nasty with me. She didn't really understand what I was doing to her, or what could happen, if we were ever caught do it together. I only licked her little pussy the first few times that we played together. But soon she became the aggressor, and wanted me to lick her pussy all the time.

We had played our game several weeks when I asked her if I could stick my cock inside her pussy. She was a little hesitant at first, but then agreed. I got myself inside of her and then began to move in and out. It didn't take long before I needed to cum. I pulled out and shot my stuff all over her belly. She liked the way my hot stuff felt hitting her stomach.

"Brad!" My little sister called for the third time. Her voice had suddenly snapped me back to the present.

"Brad! What are creamy pies?" she asked with a serious look on her face.

"What!" I stammered in response. "Where did you hear something like that?" I asked in an almost panic tone.

"I heard it from Ann. She told me to ask you if I was old enough yet to get a creamy pie!

"Well?" She waited for my answer. "Am I, or not?"

I continued to look at Cindy's crotch as I contemplated my answer. "Well, I guess so. But are you sure that you want one, since you don't really know what it is?" I asked. "I mean, you might not like it after you got one. I wouldn't want you to get mad if you didn't like it." I continued. "Do you want to watch me give one to Ann first, and then decide if you'd like one too?" I asked still not taking my eyes off her little pussy.

"Yes!" Cindy blurted with excitement. "Ann says that she loves getting them, and she knows that I will too. I want to watch you give Ann one right now if it's okay with you?" She continued.

"Sure! Let's go find Ann." I told her. It really couldn't be a better time for us to show her. My mother was going to be out of the house all afternoon, and I knew that all Ann was doing was reading in her room.

As Cindy and I walked down the hallway toward Ann's room I began to rub her little bottom through the sundress. She didn't seem to mind at all, and then turned toward me and hugged my neck. I lifted her off the floor, and then pulled her crotch up against my erection and held her there for a moment while squeezing her little ass cheeks in each hand. "Can I put my hand in your panties Cindy and feel your little pussy?" I asked her. "Are you going to rub me there like Ann does?" Cindy asked. "If that's what you want I will." I assured her.

I pushed open the door to Ann's room. "What have you been telling our little sister about creamy pie's?" I asked Cindy. "I just told her that I thought that she would like them, and told her to ask you if she was old enough to start getting them from you." She replied.

"She wants to watch me give you one first. Is that alright with you?" I asked Ann.

"After all, you did start this you know?" I continued.

"Are we going to make a creamy pie or not?" I growled at Ann.

"You haven't done that to me since I started having periods. What about getting me pregnant?" Ann grinned.

"I guess that's a risk that you're just going to have to take! You're the one that started this," I grinned back.

Ann had never wanted me to stop giving her the creamy pie's in her pussy. I'd quit because of the risk of knocking her up. Now when I fucked her, I either pulled out or cum up her ass.

I knew that giving Ann a creamy pie after she had started having periods was real risky. She started having her periods very young, only ten years old. I wanted so much to start giving them to Cindy that I was willing to take almost any risk. I had so much lust built up inside for my little sister's pussy. I had to have her no matter what. I definitely wasn't really thinking as clearly as I should have been, and it would later come back to haunt me.

"Ann! Get your panties off! I'm going to make a real big creamy pie in the hot little twat of yours!" I almost sneered.

I rolled Ann onto her back, and spread her legs wide open. I called Cindy to our side and told her to watch closely as I made a big creamy pie in her sister's pussy. I licked Ann to get her wet enough to penetrate. I then slid my cock into Ann's hot hole and started fucking away. I watched Cindy's eyes get big as a silver dollar as she watched my cock disappear inside her sister's belly. I had just given Ann all eight inches of my hard cock, and was now plowing myself into her fertile crevice.

After about five minutes Ann started to moan deeply. I quickened my pace after realizing that she was approaching her orgasm. "OH! FUCK! FUCK ME BIG BROTHER! I'M GONNA CUM!!!" She blurted out in an excited tone. "OH FUCK! FUCK MY PUSSY FULL OF YOUR HOT CREAM! MAKE A BIG CREAM PIE IN MY HOT SNATCH!" Ann whaled at the top of her lungs. OH! THAT'S IT! IT'S HAPPENING!! She almost cried.

That was all that I could take and started blasting my sister's insides with my hot seed. I was buried balls' deep with the head of my cock resting at the entrance of my sister's unprotected, eleven year old womb. I hoped that I wasn't filling her belly with my baby at that very instant. It had been almost a year since I had filled her sweet little belly full of my cum. GOD! It felt good to be doing it again.

I pulled out of Ann's pussy, and then pulled Cindy over in front of Ann's spread legs. Her pussy was tight enough that not much of it ran out of her, but instead gathered at the opening and looked like a cream filled pie. "See! That's what a creamy pie looks like!" I stated. "Do you think you want to try one too?" I asked Cindy.

"Oh yes! Could I try it too?" she quickly replied. Please make one in me too!" she pleaded.

I raised Cindy's little sundress, pulled down her panties and pushed her onto her back. I immediately buried my face between her legs and then started giving her pussy a good licking. I licked her until she was good and wet, and then slid up between her legs. I placed my cock at the opening of her tiny pussy hole, and then told her that it would hurt a little at first, but it wouldn't take long to start feeling good to her. I plunged down into her depths, breaking her cherry in one long hard stroke. I rode my little sister hard, and then felt her little pussy start contracting in her first orgasm. I rode her a few seconds longer and then filled her tender little twat with my hot pie filling.

"OH! MY! I CAN FEEL YOUR HOT STUFF GOING INSIDE MY BELLY!! OH! BRAD! IT'S GETTNG WARM INSIDE MY BELLY!!" Cindy almost purred. "I LOVE THE WAY YOUR CREAMY PIE FEELS INSIDE ME!!" She continued to pant.

I pulled out of Cindy's tight little pussy and went over to Ann's dresser and grabbed her hand mirror. I brought it over to Cindy and put in down between her legs. "Here, look at what I just made inside you." I said to Cindy. "Cool! That looks so neat!" Cindy cooed.

"Now comes the good part. You have to eat the pie you've just made or it doesn't count." I eagerly stated. "What about Ann's pie? You didn't eat her pie! " Cindy asked while not understanding why I'd let it not count.

"I saved Ann's pie for you sweetie." I replied. "I'm going to eat yours, and then you are going to eat Ann's." I continued. "Is that okay with you Cindy? Do you want to eat Ann's creamy pussy pie? I asked.

"OH! YESssssss! Can I Ann!" Cindy asked her older sister.

"Sure you can!" Ann Replied. "I'd be disappointed if you didn't." Ann told Cindy.

I leaned forward and began to eat Cindy's cream filled little twat. It was a shame that she was still a little to young to have multiple orgasms. She would have enjoyed it so much more if she had been able to.

After I finished with Cindy, I told her it was now her turn to eat a creamy pie. She didn't seem at all bashful about dipping her face in between Ann's cum soaked pussy lips. As a matter of fact, Cindy acted like it was one of the most normal things in the world. She eagerly cleaned up Ann's pussy, and in the process of doing so, licked her older sister to a pretty hard orgasm. I found out afterwards that she had given Ann orgasms that way before.

Suddenly, the door opened. I thought that we were busted for sure. Luckily, it was only my youngest sister Amy. She was now four, and very cute little blonde haired blued eyed girl. She walked over and sat down on the floor next to us.

"What you doing?" Amy asked. "How come you got no clothes on?" She continued. "What Cindy doing to Ann's potty place?" she continued to quiz the two older girls.

"I'm making Ann's potty place feel real good." Cindy answered her younger sister. "Do you want Brad to make your potty place feel good too?" Cindy asked Amy. "Will you let Brad lick your potty too, and make it feel good for you Amy?" Cindy continued.

"I guess so," Amy replied.

The little girl scooted her ass across the floor toward me. I made her lye down and I lifted the little dress that she had on to above her waist. I stared at Amy's panty crotch as my cock began to stiffen once more. I brought my nose to the center of her little white cotton panties crotch and then took a deep breath. Damn! I just loved the smell of little girl pussy. My cock was now raging hard.

I pulled Amy's panties down in one fluid move, and then buried my face in between her chubby little pussy lips. God! I loved the smell of her almost baby pussy. As my tongue crossed her little clit it got rigid, and then grew to about the size of a green pea. I knew that a little four year old girl wouldn't be able to have an orgasm, but I could sure tell that she really like the feel on my tongue there. I licked her for quite awhile before I heard Cindy ask me if I was going to give her a creamy pie too.

I looked at Ann, and she just smiled and shrugged.

I guess that I took that as a sign of being okay, and then crawled up between Amy's sweet little thighs. As I pushed my cock between her pussy lips and into her tiny opening, I knew that I could not put more than two or three inches inside of her. That should be enough to get me off, I thought to myself.

I couldn't believe how hot and tight it felt inside Amy's little body. She was taking the invasion of my cock very well. Other than her eyes being a little teary looking, she seemed to like what I was doing. I began to slowly pump about three inches in and out of her sweet little baby twat. I was just about at the point of filling Amy's pussy when the rug under my hand slid, causing me to fall forward onto Amy's body. In doing so, I rammed the full length of my hard cock into her tiny little belly. She began to cry as my balls busted inside of her and drenched her little insides with a thick coating of my hot semen.

It wasn't so much the fact that I penetrated her fully that she had started her crying. It was that the full weight of my body pinning her down scared her. When I lifted my weight off of her she stopped immediately. I fucked in and out of her as the last few spurts of cum shot out me. I about drowned my little sister's innards with my hot cum. This had been the most intense orgasm that I had ever had. I was amazed, because Amy the tiniest girl that I had ever had my cock inside of. Made me cum so hard. I knew then that I would be fucking Amy's little pussy every time that she'd let me.

"Now I have to lick up the pie that I made Amy." I told her with much excitement in my voice. I licked her good and clean. She loved the feel of my hot tongue on her little clit, and held her legs high in the air the whole time that I licked her.

I never did leave another creamy pie inside of Ann after that day. I always used Cindy and Amy's pussy for that. But it was already to late. The day that we gave instruction to Cindy was the day that Ann conceived. Her belly got huge before the baby came.

I learned from that, and stopped shooting cum inside my sister's when they got their first period. At least I got to fuck Amy for seven more years before she got hers. She became very good at getting me off too!


I'd love to hear any response to my story at kountryboy71@yahoo.com.