Cousin Swap
by Titmouse
(C)1999, All Rights Reserved
When Alec suggested that we swap partners, Eve -
the girl I had just fucked - reached over the seat and
swatted the back of his head. Jody, his date and Eve's
cousin, shrieked in outrage and called him several bad
names. He and I both laughed and pretended that it was
a joke.
When the storm had died down, Alec said, "No,
seriously, why don't we?" which set off another one.
Somewhere in the middle of it, while she was still
ragging on Alec, I noticed Jody look at me. Our eyes
met in a brief, blank glance that showed nothing but
meant everything. She was pretending to be outraged
but really wasn't. Her gaze shifted to Eve.
This time, when the storm had died down, it was
Jody who said, "No, seriously, why don't we?" And
there was a silence in the car. For a long time. We
all turned to Eve, who looked at each of us, then said,
"Okay, why don't we?"
Jody smiled at her. "Just this once," she said.
"Just this once," Eve repeated, nodding.
Even though they were committed, it was still
awkward. Neither of them could figure out how to take
the next step. As young as I was, I knew better than
to suggest anything. I'd never hear the end of it.
But I was praying like crazy.
"Change places with me," Jody said. "Come on up
here."
That was enough to get them moving. Eve, still
naked from the waist down, crawled over the front seat
with Jody's help and slipped down between them. Had
there been more light in the car, I would have had a
perfect view of her snatch. For a moment, there were
three of them in the front seat. Jody stretched her
arms around both, sort of pulling them together. She
kissed Alec deeply, then kissed Eve on the cheek.
"Take good care of my baby," she said to Eve.
"And you," she said to Alec, "fuck her good and hard.
If she's only going to get it once, it ought to be
worth it." Then she let go of them, turned to me with
a smile, and held her hands out me. I helped her climb
over the seat back to join me. My cock, which had shot
its load only a few minutes before, was suddenly rock
hard again. This was by far the sexiest thing I'd ever
done.
Alec glanced back at me. I winked with the eye
that Jody couldn't see. We'd planned this the day
before, or speculated about it anyway. We'd both said
that it was okay with us but the girls would never
agree. Surprise!
Eve looked back at me from the front seat. "Don't
look," she said, and watched me until I turned away.
I looked at Jody, and she smiled at me. Like Eve,
she was naked from the waist down. She had a tight,
ribbed undershirt over her breasts that she'd pulled
down. From the way her nipples poked the cloth out,
though, it was obvious that there was nothing under the
shirt but bare tit.
"Hi," she said.
"Hi, yourself," I said back. I put my arm around
her shoulder and she snuggled into me, raising her lips
for a kiss. I was happy to oblige.
This would never have happened if either Alec or I
had been serious about either of these girls. But we
had just met them two weekends before, up at the Lake
Shaeffer. They were staying at a cabin with Jody's
parents for two weeks; we'd driven up from Lafayette
looking for action. We'd both scored the night we met
them, all in the car together, just like tonight. We'd
made a date that night to come back this weekend. And
here we were again, all in the car together, just like
before. Almost.
Jody kissed better than Eve. I pushed my tongue
into her mouth and Jody opened wide to welcome it. The
kiss went on for a long time. After a while, I slid my
hand under her top and up to cup her tit. Jody
wriggled her chest against my hand, letting me know she
liked it.
Her tits were smaller than Eve's, but I didn't
mind. In my hand, Eve's tit had seemed ponderous and
less responsive. She seemed to get little pleasure
from my fondling them although completely willing to
let me indulge myself. Jody, in contrast, responded
eagerly to my touch, squirming and pressing back into
my hand. Her tit fit my palm perfectly, her nipple
sticking out like a pencil eraser. I hiked her blouse
up and felt the other one, too. It matched.
Jody slid her hand into my lap and wrapped her
fingers around my dick. I pushed my ass forward in
response, and my cock slid through her grip. It was
still greasy from Eve's pussy.
"Ooh," Jody whispered, "looks like you're ready."
"Hell, yes!" I whispered back.
Truth is, I'd preferred Jody from the start, but
Eve had latched on and never let go. Not that I minded
much. She was pretty enough - strawberry-blonde hair,
blue eyes and stacked, top and bottom. It's just that
I've always preferred girls with Jody's build - slim
and tight. She was cute, peppy, and sexy as hell, with
short brown hair, firm tits high on her chest, and long
slender legs. I'm pretty sure Alec would have
preferred Eve to begin with. The switch was his idea.
I glanced at the front seat. Alec was leaning
back against it, and Eve was out of sight. He let out
a long sigh, and I was pretty sure Eve was swallowing
his prick. Jody and I looked at each other and smiled.
I dropped my hand to her lap and pushed down
toward her pussy. She spread her thighs wider to give
me room, and I slipped a finger into her. I wasn't the
only one still greasy. Her cunt was slick with Alec's
cum.
"Oh, god!" Jody breathed in my ear as I churned my
finger in her tunnel. When I slid my finger out and
stroked her clit, she made a high, whiny sigh and
shuddered. Her clit felt like another nipple, but much
slicker.
"I'm still horny," she whispered in my ear. "I...
didn't make it with Alec." Her hand stroked my cock.
"That's why I wanted to change."
I pushed two fingers into her pussy. It was tight
but slippery enough that they went in easily. Jody
moaned softly.
"I wanted you anyway," she hissed. "But Eve."
"Yeah," I said. "Me, too."
"Really?"
"Yeah."
Jody rolled her hips around my probing fingers.
She pumped her hand on my prick.
"Well, you're going to get me," she whispered. "I
want you to put this..." she stroked my cock "...right
where you've got your fingers."
"Now?"
"Yeah, now."
I slid my fingers out of her. Before I could
press Jody downward onto the seat, she rolled toward me
and straddled my lap. Her bare tits were right in my
face, and I held her there while I licked and sucked on
them. She let me for a while, enjoying it, but she
wanted more. She sat down on my lap. My cock poked
up between her thighs.
Jody wrapped her fingers around me and raised up
again. She closed her eyes in concentration, biting
her lower lip between her teeth, while she maneuvered
us into position. I felt the head of my prick slip
between the lips of her pussy and into the channel.
Slowly, Jody lowered herself onto it. We were both
slick enough that I slid right up into her without much
resistance, although her cunt was tight and clutching.
I shifted my hips forward on the seat to get the last
little part of my cock into her.
"Oh, g-g-god!" she hissed. "Oh, yes. Right
there! Right in my little pussy."
I hugged her tightly, keeping her pressed onto me.
We rolled our hips together, making my cock work inside
of her.
From the front seat, we heard Alec say "C'mon, do
it! Make me shoot!" But Eve sat up instead. "No," we
heard her whisper. "I don't like that. Why don't you
just do me?" She laid back against her door, all but
the top of her head disappearing again. Alec climbed
to his knees and moved over her, looking back at me,
running his eyes down Jody's back, and waggling his
eyebrows.
"I'd do it if you asked," Jody whispered. "I'd
like to suck you. And make you come. And swallow it."
She emphasized each statement with a push of her hips,
driving me deep up into her pussy. "But I want to cum.
And I need this. Up inside me. Like that!"
I didn't say anything, just fucked her back. The
idea of poking my cock between her pouty lips and
pumping myself into her mouth until I came sounded
pretty good to me. On the other hand, I was happy
enough where I was. Jody had a way of squeezing with
her cunt muscle as she pulled back that had me clawing
the seat with my fingernails.
"Ah... Ah... Ah..." Jody panted in my ear. "That's so
good!" She had been leaning into me, but now she sat
up straight and put her hands behind her on my knees.
This made her pussy jut forward against me. We fucked
intensely for a few moments. Then she fell forward and
put her arms around me again.
"Let's lie down," she whispered. "I want to feel
you on top of me."
I was willing, although it was hard to let her
slide backward and pull her tight cunt away from my
straining prick. On the other hand, it allowed me to
cool off a little. I'd been getting close.
Jody slid sideways onto the seat and rolled onto
her back. She lifted her knees high and then scissored
her legs around my waist as I turned toward her. I
looked down between us at the pale skin of her belly,
the dark patch of fur on her mound, and the gash of her
pussy below. Slowly, I let my weight down onto her.
"Put it in me," Jody said. "I want it all the way
in me." I took my cock in hand and guided it to the
wet, welcoming hole between her legs. "Stick it in,"
she hissed. "I want your cock in me. Put it in my
pussy."
I put it in her pussy. My prick pushed between
the slick lips and oozed down into her.
"Oh, yes," Jody breathed. Her whole body quivered
as I slid in. She wrapped her arms around my neck and
hooked her legs behind mine. Her hips rose and rolled
as she helped me work my cock in all the way.
"Yes," she said again.
I had been hearing sounds from the front seat
periodically - soft grunts from Alec and sighs from
Eve. It was clear they were enjoying themselves in the
front seat as much as we were in the back. The car
rocked gently in time to Alec's rhythmic thrusts,
accompanied by faint smacks of flesh on flesh and Eve's
soft cries. It was incredibly sexy to be fucking
together like this. I drove my cock into Jody's pussy,
and she strained upward to meet and swallow it.
"Slow down, baby," I heard Eve say. "Make it
last." The rocking from the front seat stopped. Jody
and I paused, too.
Jody pulled an arm from around my neck, touched my
cheek to get my attention, then press her index finger
against her lips, signaling me to be quiet. I was
momentarily puzzled, because we weren't making any
noise. Then she slid her hand between us and began to
work it down toward where we were joined. I raised up
to give her more room.
Her fingers sought and found my cock where it half
buried in her body, then wrapped around it. She pushed
up, indicating that she wanted me to raise up farther.
Uncertain but willing, I withdrew until just the head
of my prick was still inside her. Jody wrapped her
whole hand around it and pressed upward again. I slid
completely out of her.
Jody let go of my cock. I felt her fingers
working between us at her pussy and thought for a
moment that she was fingering herself. Then she pushed
her hand even lower and did something. When her
fingers wrapped around me again, they were slick with
fluids.
Lifting her hips and pressing downward on me, Jody
nestled my stiff cock between the cheeks of her fanny
and guided the tip to rest against her butthole. She
rolled her hips in one direction and my prick in the
other, lubricating the opening. I realized that she
wanted me to fuck her there. I'd heard of ass-fucking,
of course, but I'd never even been close to doing it.
Looking at her, I opened my eyes wide to indicate
surprise, then narrowed them into a questioning look.
Jody smiled and nodded to show she knew what she was
doing. Then, slowly and lasciviously, she ran her
tongue over her lips.
With a slight tug forward on my cock, which was
harder than ever now, she urged me inward.
Tentatively, I pressed forward. The blunt head of my
cock nudged against her asshole but did not penetrate,
bending slightly instead as it met resistance.
With a look of concentration, eyes closed and lips
curled in between her teeth, Jody pushed up to meet my
downward pressing shaft. Slowly, her tight opening
began to yield. It felt to me like the head of my
prick was being squeezed by a thick rubber band. Then
it popped past the ring of flesh and into her back
channel.
Jody's eyes flew open and she whimpered in pain.
Her hand pressed against my groin, stopping me from
going farther. We froze like that for several moments.
Then she let out a sigh and relaxed. Her fingers urged
me inward again.
Slowly, gradually, with little pushes forward
followed by brief pauses, I sank my hard-on into Jody's
tight asshole. It was the first time for me, although
obviously not for her. I was amazed at how it felt -
tighter even than her tight pussy, clutching all along
the length of my invading pole, and noticeably less
slippery, despite the lubrication.
Jody's response was also amazing and incredibly
erotic. While it was clear that she had to struggle to
accommodate my straining prick in her tightly drawn ass
channel, it was equally clear that she wanted it
anyway, despite the pain. After each pause to get used
to another fraction of my length, she was ready for
more, hunching her butt toward me to signal her
willingness. She moaned faintly each time I pushed
deeper, then sighed with pleasure as her clutching
channel stretched to accept me.
I felt my pubic hair brush against her ass. I was
almost all the way in. I pushed forward again, pressed
against her ass cheeks, then spread them as my cock
slid deep into Jody's bowel. She let out a long sigh
of relief and pleasure and wrapped her arms tightly
around me. I could feel her wet pussy lips against my
groin.
From the front seat, a steady rocking had resumed
and was accelerating. Eve and Alec were both making
little noises of passion as he pounded into her.
Jody put her lips to my ear. "Fuck me," she
commanded in a whisper. "Fuck my ass, baby. Give it
to me!"
I pulled back slowly until only the head of my
cock was gripped by her ass ring and then sank it back
into her to the root. Then I did it again, faster.
And again, faster still.
Jody's eyes rolled upward. She pushed her hand
back down between us and began to play with her pussy,
stroking and rubbing her clit. Her breath was harsh in
my ear.
I was slamming my cock into her ass, now, plunging
in and out of the tightly clutching canal. Jody
squeezed at me with her ass muscle as I pushed it deep
into her hole, dragged it back, shoved it in again. I
fucked her harder and harder, smacking against her soft
ass cheeks each time I drove my prick home.
Jody was trembling and shaking. "Oh, god... oh,
god..." she repeated over and over. Alec and Eve were
pounding away in the front seat, too. I could hear him
muttering to her, too low to be understood, and Eve was
panting and whimpering as he socked it to her.
"Come on," Jody hissed through clenched teeth.
"Give it to me. Fuck me. Harder. Harder. Fuck my
ass, baby. Shove it in me. Yes. Oh, yes, baby. Ah...
Ahhhhh!"
Her fingers flew at her clit, around and around.
I drove my raging hard-on into her ass savagely,
grunting with the effort. We were both trembling and
sweating. The smell of sex permeated the car.
"Oh, yes, baby," Jody cried. "I'm so close. Do
it! Fuck me! Fuck my asshole! That's it! That's it!
Ohhhhhh!"
Her body went rigid. She yanked her hand out from
between us and threw it around my neck, squeezing me,
pressing her pelvis and ass up against me. Her body
was shaking. My cock churned in her butthole as her
pussy rubbed fiercely against my mound.
"Ahhhhhhhh, GOD!" she cried, and jerked like an
epileptic. "Yes!"
Alec was coming, too, grunting and chanting "Fuck!
Fuck! Fuck!" in time to his thrusts. Eve, whether
coming or not, was crying out in sympathy. And then a
bolt of lightning shot up my backbone, and I blew out
through my cock like a punctured tire, spewing my cum
up Jody's asshole.
"Yes, baby!" Jody urged me, her heels kicking,
spurring me. "That's it. Cum! Cum in me! Fuck me!
Cum!" And I did, in huge wracking spasms, slamming my
cock up her ass like a railroad spike.
We all lay there for a while, exhausted. Then
Alec giggled, and soon the car was rocking again with
laughter. Jody laughed so hard her butt spit me out,
not to mention a large pool of my cum.
"God, that was great," Alec said. "I've never
done anything like that."
We all agreed it had been special. We put
ourselves back together gradually, passing the girls'
clothes over the seat, all faintly embarrassed now.
Eve stayed in front with Alec, sitting close to him.
Jody snuggled into my arms in the back seat. We drove
back to Eve's folks' cabin, parking a little distance
away to say goodnight. Jody kissed me passionately
before fixing her makeup. When we got out of the car,
Eve smiled and hugged me but didn't offer a kiss. They
both waved as they walked the short distance home.
I never saw Jody again. Her family lived in
Illinois, and she had only come to spend part of summer
vacation with her cousin. I've never forgotten her,
obviously, nor the new delight she introduced me to.
I think I saw Eve, though. Months later, I think
it was early spring, my folks took me to Indianapolis
to visit relatives. As we passed through downtown, I
think I saw Eve on the sidewalk. She was with a small
group of people and she was hugely pregnant.
I've always wondered, of course. If it was indeed
Eve, it could have been my baby, or Alec's, or - given
her habits - anyone's. But it might have been mine.
Author's Note:
Yeah, right. Okay, I admit this is fantasy. In fact, I think I only had
sex in a car once, not counting a blowjob while driving the "Avenue of the
Giants" in Northern California. And I never swapped with anyone. And, with
one razor-thin possible exception, I never got anyone pregnant either. But
I did come close to having two cousins. Both mine. Years apart.
---
I welcome your comments but hate spam. Send messages to
Titmouse and put something in the subject line to clue me in.
Anything else may get deleted automatically.
My stories are also available at:
http://www.asstr-mirror.org/files/Authors/Titmouse/